Mar 22, 2015 below are excerpts from a paper titled, babbitted bearing health assessment presented at this years middle east turbomachinery symposium by john k. Turbine generator bearing failures are a leading cause of. Failure analysis of ballbearing of turbopump used in liquid. Running high boost on a standard thrust bearing can lead to premature turbo failure and a big bill. It is recommended that you idle the engine for two to three minutes to cool the bearing system before shutting down. Lubrication technology goes handinhand with understanding journal bearings and is integral to bearing design and application.
It is very common for a turbo to leak oil out the seals if the oil drain is 12mm or smaller. About 15 years ago dennis madden of atra, dave hagen of aera, ed anderson of asa, roy berndt of pera and john. Bearing failures and their causes bearing, linear motion. Try and use a 16mm inside diameter oil drain fitting and a. Since typically the journal position relative to the bearing is of interest, an eccentricity ratio is defined using the radial clearance. This paper presents a failure investigation on the damaged journal bearing, which supports the mainshaft of the turboset of a power plant. An introduction to bearing failure osborne engineering. Its vital to change the oil and coolant at recommended intervals, because old and contaminated oil damage a turbochargers bearings. Failures of engine bearings and their prevention substech. Failure analysis of journal bearing used in turboset of a.
Lack of proper lubrication oil supply will kill the bearings in a journal bearing. Bearing failures due to metaltometal contact mixed lubrication is one of the main causes of engine bearing failures. Modern turbocharger bearings can be split into two main types. The power spectrum density and support vector machine are used to monitor the healthy and faulty conditions of the bearing. Engine bearing failure analysis guide edge wear due to distorted connecting rod imperfect journal geometry cavitation erosion spinning of the bearing in the housing. Turbo failure boost turbochargers super street magazine. Failure analysis of ballbearing of turbopump used in. Depending upon the type of failure detected, recommendations are then given as to how to remedy the specific cause of damage. In fact, some journal bearings can go from normal to complete failure in a matter of minutes. Grease discoloured green wear caused by inadequate lubrication. The bearing may recover an oil film and continue to operate, and pitting will begin again. Timken bearing damage analysis with lubrication reference. Will the breaking break lose and leave shavings like a normal bearing.
Diagnosing plain bearing failures is all about recognising the telltale signs of different wear out and other failure modes. Keep your turbo s boosttodrive pressure ratio as close to 1. What are some signs i can look for when determining if a turbo is indeed the culprit. Restrictors are used in motorsport to cap the airflow and therefore, the power an engine can produce. However, it is impor tant to note that in many cases a premature bearing failure is due to a combination of sev eral of these causes. Journal bearing type turbos are critical to the above as they operate. Failure from excessive exhaust temperatures or hot shutdown of engine results in carbon buildup.
The distortion results in nonparallel orientation of the bearing and journal surfaces. This paper will present an introduction to journal bearings and lubrication. Bearings are a critical component of the turbocharger that affects its durability and reliability. For the same reason it is of great importance to reduce heat transfer from the hot. And mine shuttered like crazy at wot and caused some pretty violent jerking and noise. Turbocharger install recommendations precision turbo and. Table 21 describes bearing failures, first assigning a general term to each type of failure, then adding more detailed classifications. A manufacturing company urgently sought for causes for the failure and suitable remedy. Severe brinell marks can cause premature fatigue failure.
It was noticed that journal near the root portion was built up by welding to fill the blowholes and then hand finished. Mccloskey manager, turbomachinery, generation group electric power research institute. Looking for the root cause of a failure has caused some difference of opinions between engine and transmission builders. Turbine end heat soak into the bearing housing results in oil carbonisation and corrosion of the bearing system. Regarding the failures that occur in turbochargers, their majority up to. A journal bearing of the generator is shown in figure 4 and cross section of it is show n in figure 5 1. Vibration analysis can still be used for diagnosing journal bearing problems. It is caused by running the bearing at load above the fatigue limit. The debris that enters the oil begins abrasion damage. Common causes for turbocharger failure this section will discuss the four primary causes for turbocharger failure. Troubleshooting bearing and lube oil system problems by thomas h.
Oil contamination a mostly visible as scratches and score lines on the journal bearing and the shaft. All small twin journal bearing turbocharger applications utilizing turbocharger sizes up to hp42 should utilize a. The failure mechanism of discussed sample which was related to an interfering part of steam turbine journal bearing determined as fretting fatigue with considering the conditions of fretting wear and some visible features of fretting pits and cracks on the surface without any changes through microstructure and chemical composition. Journal bearings as so sensitive parts of steam turbines are very susceptible to. Tensile stresses can be very high in tightly fitted bearing components. An investigation into failure analysis of interfering part of. Typical problems with rotating machines comprises of high speed rotating parts are often due to bearing failure. Due to geometry misalignment axial mismatch between journal and bearing centre lines misalignment of bearing housing or shaft journal deflection under load corrective actions realign bearings switch to a more misalignment tolerant design such as, tilting pad, equalised. It is important to note that when a turbocharger fails for any reason, there is almost always secondary and often more severe damage caused by the resulting shaft motion. Due to geometry misalignment axial mismatch between journal and bearing centre lines misalignment of bearing housing or shaft journal deflection under load corrective actions realign bearings.
I have never seen a turbo fail like this and would like to identify the cause. Other potential bearing technologies include foil air bearings and active magnetic bearings. Therefore, as a rule, there is plenty of time to prepare for a change of bearing. Turbomaster is a company devoted exclusively to the turbochargers business since its foundation in 1980, i. It could cause wear, vibration and even system failure. Troubleshooting bearing and lube oil system problems thomas h. Journal bearing vs ball bearing turbos cost vs performance. A leadfree and corrosion resistant journal and thrust bearing system for. Accelerated wear when the bearing is not overheated and only shining appearance of the bearing surface is observed. Below are excerpts from a paper titled, babbitted bearing health assessment presented at this years middle east turbomachinery symposium by john k. The nonparallelism causes localized excessive wear of the bearing surface due to metaltometal.
The ball bearing is also far more tolerant to marginal lube conditions, lessoning the possibility of turbo failure on engine shut down. Attempting to remove such components by cutting the cone inner race may. Bearing housing 2 and cover lid 9 are made of cast iron. Read the text associated with the picture, so as to get a better understanding of why the bearing failed. The manual classified 16 sepa rate modes of bearing failure that are likely to occur in hydrody. With the ball bearing cartridge the damping and control over shaft motion is far more durable and superior over the journal bearing. Bearing material fatigue is the second cause of the bearing failure. Causes of engine bearing failure the aim of this manual is to enable the reader to diagnose the causes of engine bearing failure through visual inspection of the bearings. Generally turbobearing failure can play out in two waysa quick death by oil starvation or a long, drawn out suffering compliments of an imbalance. If load acting to the bearing is higher than the fatigue strength of the material, fatigue cracks form on the bearing surface, spread towards the back layer and may result in peeling off the bearing material. All single journal bearing turbocharger applications utilizing turbocharger sizes hp47 and up should utilize 6an or 38 inch inside diameter oil feed line. The major type of engine bearing failure is material fatigue. An introduction to bearing failure turbo power services.
An investigation into failure analysis of interfering part. Pdf turbocharger lubrication lubricant behavior and factors. Isoviscous simulation models for journal bearings and. Each rolling contact bearing failure leaves traces of evidences on what caused its failure. Dark patches can be seen at some portions of the bearing in fig. Finally, refer to the checklist that closes out the series for suggestions on how to avoid a repetition of the. One of the engine ground tests was aborted due to the failure of a selfaligning deep groove ball bearing used in turbo pump of a liquid rocket engine.
My con reasons to using a journal vs ball bearing are as follows. Timken bearing damage analysis with lubrication reference guide. On the characteristics of misaligned journal bearings. The development of a leadfree corrosion resistant bearing system. Examination of th6 failure mode ohn reveals the true cause of failure.
The first thing to look for is an illustration that depicts similar damage to the failed bearing. Lubricant has gradually been used up or has lost its lubricating properties. A 360 degree thrust bearing is recommended if you intend running more than 1 bar 14. Fatigue failure in diagonally opposed areas in top and bottom halves causes load concentration on one area of bearing. How much oil pressure to run to your turbo turbo lab. This process may occur several times before the inevitable catastrophic bearing failure. As you can see it has split and then a corner failed. The damage position is located at the hydrodynamic. Turbo oil supply is critical, always check oil pressures are correct avoid using silicone on oil gaskets as they can easily become detached and block oil passages clean or replace oil inlet pipes to remove carbon deposits or sludge signs of oil starvation. Once the bearing surface becomes incapable of supporting an oil film, the bearing will wipe. All small twin journal bearing turbocharger applications utilizing turbocharger sizes up to hp42 should utilize a 6an or 38 inch inside. Further benefit may be had, when ball bearings are used usually angular.
Bearing failure analysis type of damge failure we ar wear caused by abrasive particles. Rotor whirl, asme journal of engineering for power, pp. Select a bearing material with higher load capacity check. Turbocharger failure diagnosis guidelines cummins inc. The damage position is located at the hydrodynamic lubrication area of the bearing. The basic theory for the misalignment and some results for the circular journal bearing are also presented to show the general trends of the misalignment. How to diagnose plain bearing failures neale consulting. In industry, the use of journal bearings is specialized for rotating machinery both low and high speed.
Thrust bearing failures are not usually very common, but when they do happen the cost of repair can be significant. An investigation into failure analysis of interfering part of a steam. Contained within the turbocharger bearing system are two journal bearings figure. The turbo im talking about is a vf39 has a little in and out shaft play, but the wastegate crack is longer than i have ever seen one. Friction characterization of turbocharger bearings diva. Failure analysis of one such bearing is the subject of this paper. A lack of lubrication can result in catastrophic damage to the bearing systems which can occur within seconds of the turbocharger commencing operation.
Tom mccloskey, is the man ager, turbomachinery, in the generation group at the electric power research insti tute ep rl in palo alto, california. The rest of the bearing designs to be discussed are more complex because they consist of two bores the bearing set bore and the pad machines bore. Material transfer caused by high temperature due to friction from bearings to other thrust parts and the journal bearing diameter of. The fatigue cracks form on the surface and propagate. Turbocharger, garrett t3t4e, 60 trim 4 comp hsg, antisurge. Types of failure bearing failures main cause reference failures failure details rolling fatigue flaking. Careful inspection of the failed bearing will usually reveal vital visual clues that can lead to a potential cause for the failure. Bearing failure analysis type of damgefailure we ar wear caused by abrasive particles. The axial force acting on the turbocharger thrust bearing has a great influence on the oil film. One of the engine ground tests was aborted due to the failure of a selfaligning deep groove ball bearing used in turbopump of a liquid rocket engine. Drain for a turbocharger, it is important to have as large of and oil drain possible and never use a restrictor in a journal bearing turbocharger. Mccloskey manager, turbomachinery, generation group electric power research institute palo alto, california thomas h.
If the original cause of failure is not identified it is likely the same type of failure will occur on the remanufactured turbo. Any static overload or severe impact can cause brinelling. I thought this would be journal bearing failure but after taking it apart the thrust bearing has broken and jammed the turbo up. Journal bearings of the crank pin of a few tyre moulding presses were failing frequently. In order to examine the causes of failure, the units were dissembled and cleaned. Flaking is a relatively long, drawnout process and makes its presence known by increasing noise and vibration levels in the bearing. Scoring to thrust parts scoring to the journal bearing diameter. This does not mean to say that the bearing cannot be used after then. Power plant, turbogenerator, journal bearing, lubrication. When a bearing does fail, it is important to determine the exact cause so apprcipriate adiusfments can be made. Metaltometal contact may appear in the following forms of the bearing wear.
1399 179 1014 487 272 343 1067 296 1412 245 538 449 1071 1054 1152 88 1336 1057 922 924 1253 474 251 85 599 140 11 1262 549 758 930 411 528 884 425 630 10 769 992 221 1185 1250 248 168 1225 31